Apartments and villas in Fire Island | no car needed

View larger map

Price per night

£442 Average

Price per night

to

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Location

  • United States
  • New York
  • Baldwin

Location

  • All locations
  • Cherry Grove (2)
  • Fair Harbor (2)
  • Fire Island Pines (2)
  • Kismet (1)

More

Less

Property type

More

Less

Payment Protection
To book this holiday home you need to pay through the Holiday Lettings website. We can’t protect your payment if you don’t pay through us. Learn more

13 Holiday homes

Filters applied: Car not required (8)

Travellers going to Fire Island are booking May dates now. Secure your holiday home today and have the perfect trip.

(1) Very Good 

1 / 16

Holiday home in Fair Harbor

Fire Island / Fair Harbor

4 7 3 nights min stay

House / 4 bedrooms / sleeps 7 / 3 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £521 / night

£2639 / week

Book

from £521 / night

1 / 24

Cherry Grove holiday home rental

Fire Island / Cherry Grove

1 4 7 nights min stay

House / 1 bedroom / sleeps 4 / 7 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £276 / night

£1242 - £3173 / week

Book

from £276 / night

(6) Excellent 

1 / 30

Holiday home in Kismet

Fire Island / Kismet

4 8 Min stay varies

House / 4 bedrooms / sleeps 8 / Min stay varies

Add to shortlist

from £226 / night

£1389 - £2431 / week

Book

from £226 / night

1 / 21

Fair Harbor holiday cottage rental

Fire Island / Fair Harbor

3 6 6 nights min stay

Cottage / 3 bedrooms / sleeps 6 / 6 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £591 / night

£3473 / week

Book

from £591 / night

1 / 21

Cherry Grove holiday home rental

Fire Island / Cherry Grove

2 4 7 nights min stay

House / 2 bedrooms / sleeps 4 / 7 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £250 / night

£1737 / week

Book

from £250 / night

1 / 16

Home rental in Fire Island Pines with swimming pool

Fire Island / Fire Island Pines

4 8 4 nights min stay

House / 4 bedrooms / sleeps 8 / 4 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £1042 / night

£6945 / week

Book

from £1042 / night

1 / 6

Holiday log cabin with shared pool in Fire Island Pines

Fire Island / Fire Island Pines

1 2 2 nights min stay

Log cabin / 1 bedroom / sleeps 2 / 2 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £174 / night

£1042 / week

Book

from £174 / night

1 / 14

Fire Island holiday cottage rental

Long Island / Fire Island

3 6 7 nights min stay

Cottage / 3 bedrooms / sleeps 6 / 7 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £457 / night

£3195 / week

Book

from £457 / night

More results near

Distance approx 23.47 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 16

Holiday apartment in Baldwin

New York / Baldwin

2 2 3 nights min stay

Apartment / 2 bedrooms / sleeps 2 / 3 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £207 / night

£1173 / week

Book

from £207 / night

Distance approx 23.99 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 56

Holiday home in Uniondale

New York / Uniondale

7 13 3 nights min stay

House / 7 bedrooms / sleeps 13 / 3 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £348 / night

£2084 / week

Book

from £348 / night

Distance approx 24.57 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 25

Holiday home in Westhampton Beach

New York / Westhampton Beach

3 8 4 nights min stay

House / 3 bedrooms / sleeps 8 / 4 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £380 / night

£2759 / week

Book

from £380 / night

Distance approx 27.52 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 15

Holiday condo in Long Beach

Long Island / Long Beach

1 2 7 nights min stay

Condo / 1 bedroom / sleeps 2 / 7 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £120 / night

£834 / week

Book

from £120 / night

Distance approx 27.75 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

(4) Excellent 

1 / 16

Long Beach holiday home let

Long Island / Long Beach

5 11 5 nights min stay

House / 5 bedrooms / sleeps 11 / 5 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £759 / night

£5311 - £5725 / week

Book

from £759 / night

Don’t let an old browser slow down your holiday

Your browser is out of date and might not work well with our website. Download the latest version to speed up your hunt for the perfect holiday home.

Just click on the icons to get to the download page