Fire Island cottages: Luxury cottages in Fire Island

View larger map

Price per night

£456 Average

Price per night

to

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Location

  • United States
  • New York
  • Mastic Beach

Location

  • All locations

More

Less

Property type

More

Less

Payment Protection
To book this holiday home you need to pay through the Holiday Lettings website. We can’t protect your payment if you don’t pay through us. Learn more

9 Holiday homes

Filters applied: Walking holidays (1)

Don't let other travellers get your favourite Fire Island holiday home. You're so close to securing your perfect getaway. Book today.

1 / 14

Fire Island holiday cottage rental

Long Island / Fire Island

3 6 7 nights min stay

Cottage / 3 bedrooms / sleeps 6 / 7 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £457 / night

£3195 / week

Book

from £457 / night

More results near

Distance approx 19.9 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

(1) Excellent 

1 / 24

Holiday home in Mastic Beach

New York / Mastic Beach

3 6 Min stay varies

House / 3 bedrooms / sleeps 6 / Min stay varies

Add to shortlist

from £348 / night

£2431 / week

Book

from £348 / night

Distance approx 27.15 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 7

Holiday home with tennis court in Westhampton

Hamptons / Westhampton

5 10 7 nights min stay

House / 5 bedrooms / sleeps 10 / 7 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £946 / night

£6621 / week

Book

from £946 / night

Distance approx 27.43 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 42

Holiday home in New York City

New York / New York City

2 10 Min stay varies

House / 2 bedrooms / sleeps 10 / Min stay varies

Add to shortlist

from £1389 / night

£9723 / week

Book

from £1389 / night

Distance approx 27.52 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 15

Holiday condo in Long Beach

Long Island / Long Beach

1 2 7 nights min stay

Condo / 1 bedroom / sleeps 2 / 7 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £120 / night

£834 / week

Book

from £120 / night

Distance approx 28.12 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 22

Home rental in Wading River

New York / Wading River

4 8 Min stay varies

House / 4 bedrooms / sleeps 8 / Min stay varies

Add to shortlist

from £209 / night

£1459 / week

Book

from £209 / night

Distance approx 29.54 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

1 / 36

Holiday home with golf nearby in New York City

New York / New York City

7 20 Min stay varies

House / 7 bedrooms / sleeps 20 / Min stay varies

Add to shortlist

from £2778 / night

£19445 / week

Book

from £2778 / night

Distance approx 29.67 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

(1) Excellent 

1 / 19

Glen Cove holiday home rental

New York / Glen Cove

5 9 4 nights min stay

House / 5 bedrooms / sleeps 9 / 4 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £380 / night

£2621 - £3007 / week

Book

from £380 / night

Distance approx 30.37 miles from Fire Island Show on Map

(3) Good 

1 / 10

Holiday home with golf nearby in Baiting Hollow

New York / Baiting Hollow

2 5 3 nights min stay

House / 2 bedrooms / sleeps 5 / 3 nights min stay

Add to shortlist

from £115 / night

£660 / week

Book

from £115 / night

Don’t let an old browser slow down your holiday

Your browser is out of date and might not work well with our website. Download the latest version to speed up your hunt for the perfect holiday home.

Just click on the icons to get to the download page