I've been renting in Fair Harbor for over 20 years. What you need in a Fire Island rental is to be near the ferry, the store but still have and quiet and privacy. You need beach chairs, umbrellas, ga… More
"Clean updated house with all amentities, A/C and great location. Great Beach."
Great cottage in Kismet - good, convenient location - easy walk to bay/shops, water taxi/ferry & and beach. Property is clean, updated and open. Nice floors and paint colors - very beachy. Outdoor sh… More
22 Jun 2015
"Cozy beach home, perfect for a getaway with friends!"
Stayed at this house for a weekend in June and it was just what we were looking for! A 2 minute walk to the beach and SO easy to find from the ferry. The house was absolutely spotless when we walked… More
16 Jun 2015
My best friend is getting married at the end of this month so I rented the house for us and the rest of the bridal party for a bachelorette weekend getaway. The house was absolutely perfect, and the p… More
My friend and I went up for new years. Rob was very nice to us. He informed us where things were locally and how to get to the train station. He gave us our privacy. No problems at all. When we needed… More
It was very nice having Casey and friend stay. They were quiet, respectful and left the place clean. I certainly recommend her/them!
What a great place. We immediately felt at home and found every ammenity one could think of. The pictures don't nearly do justice to the size and beauty of this home. My only wish is we could have st… More
7 Jul 2014
The pictures certainly do not do this house justice, it is far more impressive and larger in person. The pool table is a great crowd pleaser and the marble table is delightful as well. Definitely woul… More
16 Jul 2015
"Best Family Vacation Ever"
The Webby Beach House was perfect for our family vacation of 6 that included 3 generations. The nature park, beach, and play ground all with in walking distance meant there was always something to do… More
I welcomed my friends from Germany to the U.S. What made the stay super sweet for them and for myself was this rental. It had everything we needed. I'm a local in Westhampton, so I was able to show th… More
14 Jun 2014
"Green an Quiet"
We have rented the house for a long week. The contact with Christine was excellent. The info and the keys were all where they should be. The house is clean even for German standards. The neighbourhood… More
As I walked into the house for the weekend that we spent there for my sister's bachelorette party, I was in awe of how gorgeous the property was. The house was absolutely beautiful! It was very spaci… More
15 Jul 2014
"Even better than I had hoped for!"
What a beautiful home and how amazing Debbie is! She stayed around to give us a tour of the house which I am glad she did because there was so much to offer. She really made this such a wonderful expe… More
5 Aug 2014
"Villa met prachtige ligging aan het water."
Mooi ruim huis aan het water met prachtig uitzicht. Rust ondanks nabijheid van vliegveld JFK. Nieuw meubilair en aan alles is gedacht, comfortabele bedden, handdoeken ook voor zwembad, wasmachine/drog… More
We were looking for a nice, quiet, comfortable place with most of the thing you find in a house. That was it. Enjoyed our stay, our food, beach 5 minutes walk, weather was beautiful. Wish can do it mo… More
You were such a pleasure to have. We hope you will come back. You and your family are always welcome. We are very glad you liked our cottage.
3 Sep 2015
"Cozy Cottage with a short walk to the beach"
The cottage was very basic, clean and comfortable that includes all of the basic needs in the kitchen and bathroom. Please be aware that there is only one double bed and one twin in private bedrooms. … More
Thank you so much for staying. Thank you for your feedback. We value you as our guest and hope you will come again. There will be many updates and we think you will enjoy it even more next time.
15 Oct 2015
We were looking for a quiet place to stay that accepted pets. The cottage was comfortable and had room for our grandchildren to stay with us. I loved that the beach was so close for long walks with ou… More
Anne, It was a pleasure to have you stay in our home. We hope
you come back and visit the next time you are in the area.
We had 4 great sunny days at Baiting Hollow.
The cottage has a warm, cozy atmosphere (-> photos).
The beach is gorgeous, just as perferct as you would wish for swimming, relaxing or watching beautif… More
Thank you for taking the time to write a review.
I am so glad the weather was perfect for you.
Can't wait for you to join us again!!!
9 May 2015
"This cozy, adorable beach cottage is perfect for a small group."
I was looking for a place near the beach to celebrate my birthday with a couple of good friends and this cottage was perfect. The house is lovely and comfortable and while it's only two bedrooms we we… More
So glad you enjoyed your birthday celebration!
The back deck is great for entertaining and very private.
I take great pride in sharing our cottage with all of you.
Please come back and tell all of your friends to visit with us!
3 Sep 2015
"Totally relaxing, I loved the screened in front porch!"
My adult daughter and I spent 3 wonderful nights in this charming cottage. We spent alot of time in the serenity of the front porch, surrounded by beautiful trees. We walked to the beach every day and… More
Thank you so much for taking the time to write a review on our cottage.
We are so glad that you have found it !!!
We love our cottage on the north fork. It is a great break for us from our busy lives.
The fall is also a great time to visit.
Feel free to contact me when you wish to return.
Thanks again for keeping the cottage so clean on your departure.!!